
To grade your own website, answer twelve yes-or-no questions in four areas. Can people find you? Does it work on a phone? Is the first impression clear? Is everything behind the scenes working? Count your yeses. The score tells you whether a few fixes will do or it's time to start fresh.
I built a free version of this check, Grade My Website, so you don't have to keep score on a napkin. Twelve questions, your score and a plain-English fix list right on the page, and no email needed. This post walks through every question so you know what you're checking and why it matters.
Why grade your site before you rebuild
A lot of owners decide they need a new website because the old one just feels off. That feeling is usually right. But "off" isn't a plan.
Sometimes the fix is small. A phone number that won't tap to call. Hours that changed two years ago. A contact form that quietly stopped sending. Those are an afternoon of work, not a rebuild.
Other times the problem is the foundation. A homepage that doesn't say what you do. Nothing about where you work. No proof that you're real. Patching that kind of site can cost more time than starting clean.
Grading it first tells you which one you've got. It's the same thing I do at the start of any project, just in a form you can run yourself.
How the self-check works
The Grade My Website page has twelve questions in four groups of three. Each one has a short hint telling you exactly how to check it.
You answer Yes, No, or Not sure. Here's what happens with each:
Yes counts toward your score.
No adds that item to your fix list, with a plain note on what to do about it.
Not sure goes on a separate "worth checking" list. It doesn't count as a yes, so it lowers your score until you find out.
Your score is the share of questions you answered yes, shown as a percentage. At 60% or higher, the site is in decent shape, and your fix list is the to-do. Under 60%, the page tells you so plainly and lets you choose between working through the list and starting fresh.
Everything shows up on the page as you go. Nothing gets emailed, and nobody calls you.
You'll want two things nearby: your phone and a computer. Several questions only make sense when you check them on your own phone.
Part 1: Can people find you?
When you search your business name on Google, does your website show up on the first page? Use a private browser window, so your own search history doesn't skew the results. If you don't show up for your own name, start with your Google Business Profile and make sure your business name is stated clearly on the site. I wrote a full walkthrough on getting listed on Google Business Profile.
Does your site say which towns or areas you serve? Look at the homepage and the footer. It should be in words, not only on a map. Google reads words.
If you ask an AI assistant about businesses like yours in your area, does yours come up? Try ChatGPT or Google's AI mode. If you don't come up, your site probably needs clearer language about what you do and where you do it.
Part 2: On a phone
Can you read everything without pinching or zooming? Open your site on your own phone, not a computer. Plenty of your visitors will only ever see the phone version.
Can you tap your phone number to call? Tap it. Your phone should offer to dial. If it doesn't, that's one of the simplest fixes on the list, and one of the most useful.
Does your site open without a pop-up covering the page? A pop-up that looks fine on a computer can cover the whole screen on a phone. Remove it or delay it.
Part 3: First impressions
Could a stranger tell what you do, and who it's for, within five seconds? Show a friend your homepage for five seconds, then ask them. If they can't say it back, the headline needs work. What you do, for whom, in plain words.
Is there a clear button to call, book, or get started near the top? Look at the first screen, before you scroll. One clear button beats three competing ones.
Does your site show proof? Reviews, photos of your real work, or how long you've been in business. Stock photos don't count.
Part 4: Behind the scenes
When you send yourself a message through your contact form, does it reach your inbox? Fill it out like a customer would, then check your inbox and your spam folder. This is the one I'd check first. A broken form doesn't look broken. It just goes silent.
Does your browser show your site as secure? Look at the left end of the address bar, on a computer and on your phone. If you see "Not secure," your site needs https, and some visitors will leave before they read a word.
Is everything up to date? Hours, services, prices, staff, the copyright year in the footer, and any special that ended months ago. Outdated details make a business look closed, even when it's busy.
Reading your score: fix it or rebuild it?
Here's how I'd read the results, honestly.
If your no's are mostly in Parts 2 and 4, you probably don't need a new website. Tap-to-call, pop-ups, forms, security, and hours are fixable. Work through the list yourself or send it to whoever manages your site.
If your no's are mostly in Parts 1 and 3, that's a different kind of problem. When people can't find you, can't tell what you do, and can't see proof, the issue usually isn't one setting. It's not a talent problem. It's a foundation problem. That's when starting clean is often simpler than patching.
If you answered Not sure a lot, that's useful too. Spend twenty minutes finding out before you decide anything.
If you do land on a rebuild, you don't have to sign up for a big project to get it right. I've been a graphic designer for more than 25 years, with nearly 15 of those years in real estate marketing in Rochester. My Single-Page Website is $600 flat. It's one clear homepage written in your voice, with click-to-call, a short contact form, and your Google Business Profile and Bing listing set up as part of the price. If you need a logo and colors too, brand identity is $700, with a website or on its own.
I keep the scope defined on purpose. It lets me bring real experience to small businesses at a price that makes sense for them, because I want those businesses to do well. Clear scope, flat pricing, and files you own.
What this looks like for a local business
The questions are the same everywhere, but the answers that matter most shift a little by town.
In Webster, a lot of small businesses work from a truck or a home office. Plowing, landscaping, contractors, cleaners. For them, tap-to-call and a clear list of service areas carry most of the weight.
In Canandaigua, businesses sell to locals and to visitors searching from a phone near the lake. Accurate hours and a page that loads and reads well on a phone come first.
In Fairport, plenty of owners are makers who are great at their craft and short on time. A homepage that says what they make in one line does a lot of quiet work.
I work with small businesses across Greater Rochester, and you can see the full list on my areas served page. If you'd like to see how the basics fit together before you grade anything, my post on what a small business website needs and what it costs is a good companion to this one.
A calm next step
Grab your phone and give your site an honest look. Grade your website here. It's free, it takes twelve answers, and your score and fix list stay on your screen. Whatever it says, you'll know what to do next.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I grade my own website?
Answer twelve yes-or-no questions about whether people can find you, whether the site works on a phone, whether your homepage makes a clear first impression, and whether things like your contact form and security are working. Count the yeses. My free Grade My Website check does the scoring and builds your fix list for you.
Do I need to give my email to use Grade My Website?
No. Your score and fix list show up right on the page as you answer. Nothing gets emailed, and no one follows up unless you reach out.
What's a good score?
On my self-check, 60% or higher means your site is in decent shape and your fix list is your to-do. Under 60% usually points to a foundation problem, and starting fresh may be simpler than patching.
What does "Not sure" do to my score?
It doesn't count as a yes, so it lowers your score. Those questions go on a separate "worth checking" list. Check them on your phone or computer, then answer again.
Should I fix my website or rebuild it?
If your no's are about phone use, forms, security, or outdated details, fix them. If people can't find you or can't tell what you do, a rebuild is often simpler. A Single-Page Website from me is $600 flat, with your Google Business Profile set up as part of it.